To these reviews, I'll add my own reasons for choosing the Starlite and my first hands-on impression of the pack.
I weighed the three components of my Starlite with a Brecknell model 311 digital scale. Here are the results.
Pack body: 19.5 oz.
Hip belt with pockets: 5.2 oz.
Aluminum stay: 4.4 oz.
The removable hip belt and aluminum stay make three pack configurations possible:
- Pack without belt or stay (19.5 oz)
- Pack with belt but without stay (24.7 oz)
- Pack with belt and stay (29.1 oz)
The first configuration rides comfortably with my sub-10 lb base weight and a 16 lb initial pack weight.
For initial pack weights over 16 lbs, I add the hip belt for a more comfortable carry. The belt also takes most of the pressure off the shoulder straps, which are attached to the back panel with a Velcro strap that makes the pack adjustable to the user's torso length. According to a few other Starlite users, this Velcro strap can support over 20 or even 30 lbs on its own, so I'm not concerned about a strap failure.
If my initial pack weight will exceed 25 lbs, I add the aluminum stay as well. While I rarely approach a 25 lb pack weight, I did test a water-heavy 31.2 lb initial pack weight with an overnight hike in the Joshua Tree backcountry. During the hike in with this load, the Starlite felt solid, stable, and as comfortable as 30 lbs on my back would likely feel. The next morning, I hiked out with about 23 lbs (8 lbs fewer consumables--mostly water), which was very comfortable in the Starlite. The aluminum stay would come in handy on the PCT through-hike I hope to do one year. With a 17 lb base weight rating and a 35 lb max load rating, the Starlite would make a capable through-hiking pack.
|SMD Starlite, front|
|SMD Starlite, back|
It's this potential through-hike that led me to a larger capacity bag like the Starlite. I also wanted to have room to pack my sleeping pad rather than lash it to the outside of the pack. My standard gear fills 25-30 L, my sleeping pad fills 9 L, and my consumables typically fill 5-10 L; therefore, I was looking for a 40-50 L bag. The Starlite has a 49 L main bag, a 6.5 L extension collar, and 13 L in external mesh pockets. With a 49 L main bag, I can leave the extension collar for overflow consumables and the mesh pockets for water bottles and wet/dirty gear.
|compressed 16 lb pack weight|
Even though I'm pretty careful with my gear, I like the 210 denier Dyneema Diamond ripstop used for the pack bag and the 420 denier pack cloth used in high-wear areas. The mesh pocket material feels coarse and fairly tough as well.
Finally, here are a few features I like enough to highlight.
|pack top open|
|pack top closed|
The suspension pocket for my sleeping pad is recessed into the body of the main pack via the back panel and lets me remove my pad without disturbing the other contents of my pack. This makes stretching out for a midday rest a lot more convenient.
|back panel sleeping pad pocket|
The external mesh pockets are a generous size, and they are arranged in a pretty unique and useful way. I keep miscellaneous quick-access items in the upper side pocket, and I'm able to roll up my tent in a ground cloth and slip it neatly in the long side pocket.
|Starlite with 31 lb load|